Arrest Records, Mugshots, and Court Dockets: What Can Actually Be Removed From Google?

It is the most common and terrifying question in online reputation: "I was arrested five years ago, the charges were dropped, but my mugshot is still the first thing employers see. Can I delete it?"

The answer is complex because it involves three different powerful forces: State Law, Google Policy, and Website Greed.

This guide explains the stark reality of removing criminal records in 2025, separating the "easy" removals from the ones that require legal warfare—and where professional help steps in.

---

The Big Myth: "Expungement Deletes It From the Internet"

This is the most painful misunderstanding.

• Expungement is a court order that tells government agencies (courts, police, FBI) to seal your file.
• The Internet is private. Google, mugshot sites, and local newspapers are not government agencies. They are private companies protected by the First Amendment (in the US).

Reality Check: You can have a perfectly clean legal record, but a "dirty" Google search result, because the website hosting your mugshot has no legal obligation to care about your expungement order... unless you force them to.

---

Category 1: The "Predatory" Mugshot Sites (Easier to Remove)

Google has policies against sites that charge money to remove mugshots (sometimes called "exploitative removal practices"). Sites like BustedNewspaper, Mugshots.com, and Arrests.org may fall under these policies.

Google's "Exploitative Removal" Policy

If a site requires payment to remove content, Google considers it "exploitative."

• The Fix: You can report these specific URLs directly to Google using the "Exploitative Removal Practices" form.
• The Result: Google will de-index the page. The page still exists on the mugshot site, but it disappears from Google Search results.
• Success Rate: High (for recognized predatory sites).

---

Category 2: Local News & Police Blotters (Hard to Remove)

If your arrest was covered by the local town newspaper or a TV station, Google treats this as "Journalism" and "Public Interest." They will almost never de-index reputable news articles on their own.

Your Options:

1. The "Unpublish" Request: You must contact the editor of the newspaper directly.
2. The "No-Index" Negotiation: Many progressive newsrooms now have "Right to be Forgotten" programs. They won't delete the article, but they might add a noindex tag code to it, telling Google to stop showing it, while keeping it in their own archives.
3. The Legal Argument: If the article is factually false (e.g., it says you were "Convicted" but you were "Acquitted"), you have grounds for a defamation/libel claim to force a correction or removal.

---

💡 Pro Tip: Document the outcome of your case. If charges were dropped, dismissed, or you were acquitted, that documentation becomes your most powerful tool in removal requests.

---

Category 3: Data Brokers & Background Check Sites (Tedious but Possible)

Sites like Whitepages, Spokeo, TruthFinder, and BeenVerified scrape public court records.

• The Good News: Most have "Opt-Out" portals.
• The Bad News: There are 100+ of them. As soon as you remove yourself from one, another one scrapes the data.
• The Fix: This is a volume game. You either spend your weekends doing manual opt-outs, or you pay a service to automate the "Opt-Out" submissions every month.

---

How Professional Services Handle Criminal Records

When the free Google forms don't work (especially for news articles or stubborn database sites), we deploy a three-tier strategy.

Tier 1: The "Expungement Leverage"

If you have a sealed or expunged record, we use that court order as a weapon.

• We send certified letters to the hosting sites (not just Google).
• While they aren't always legally required to comply, many risk-averse legal departments will delete the page rather than fight a lawyer-backed request involving sealed court documents.

Tier 2: The "De-Indexing" Negotiation

For news outlets that refuse to delete the article, we negotiate for de-indexing or anonymization.

• We appeal to editorial standards: "This minor charge from 10 years ago is no longer newsworthy and is causing disproportionate harm."
• We have established contacts at editorial desks who handle these specific "fresh start" requests.

Tier 3: Suppression (The "Burial" Method)

If a major newspaper (e.g., The New York Times) refuses to remove a true article, no one can force them to.

• In this worst-case scenario, we pivot to Suppression.
• We build a network of positive, high-authority content (personal websites, press releases, professional profiles) to push the negative result to Page 2 or 3.
• Stat: Less than 5% of searchers click past Page 1. If we can't delete it, we make sure no one sees it.

---

🛡️ Have an Expunged Record? We can leverage your court documents to pressure websites that won't respond to regular requests. Get a free case evaluation →

---

Summary Checklist: What To Do With Your Record

| If the Result Is On... | Action Required | Difficulty | |------------------------|-----------------|------------| | Mugshot / Shaming Site | Report to Google as "Exploitative Removal Practice" | 🟢 Easy | | Data Broker (Spokeo, etc.) | Use their specific "Opt-Out" form (repeatedly) | 🟡 Medium (Tedious) | | Government Court Site | Get a lawyer to file for Expungement/Sealing | 🟡 Medium (Legal) | | Local News / Blog | Requires negotiation with Editor or legal threat | 🔴 Hard |

---

The Cost of Inaction

| Impact | Consequence | |--------|-------------| | Job Applications | 73% of employers Google candidates | | Housing | Landlords routinely search applicants | | Dating | First-date Google searches are standard | | Business | Clients and partners will find it | | Peace of Mind | Constant anxiety about discovery |

---

Pricing for Arrest Record Removal

| Service | Standard | Priority | |---------|----------|----------| | Mugshot Removal | $599 | $899 | | Arrest Records Removal | $599 | $899 | | Complete Removal (Source + Google) | $1,799 | — |

All plans include:

• Google de-indexing requests
• Data broker opt-outs
• Exploitative site removal
• Money-back guarantee if removal isn't possible

Get Started Now →

---

Final Word: Don't Let a Past Mistake Define Your Digital Future

If you are tired of explaining a mugshot or an old arrest to every date and employer, professional help can audit your results and tell you exactly which ones can be killed, which can be buried, and how to finally get your name back.

Start Your Removal Request →

Learn About Arrest Record Services →

Check Our Pricing →

---

Every case is different. We'll give you an honest assessment of what's possible before you pay anything.

---

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Expungement and record sealing laws vary by state. Content removal from Google and third-party websites cannot be guaranteed, as final decisions rest with Google and website operators. Consult a licensed attorney for legal matters.